NAIA All-Americans

Baseball

  • 1987 – Tim Redman – First Team

Men’s Basketball

  • 1959 – Charles Grote – First Team
  • 1959 – Raymond Withrow – Third Team
  • 1962 – Dick Vories – Second Team
  • 1962 – Joe Farris – Third Team
  • 1963 – Cecil Tuttle – First Team
  • 1964 – Cecil Tuttle – First Team
  • 1964 – Dick Vories – Second Team
  • 1969 – Kenny Davis – Second Team
  • 1970 – Kenny Davis – First Team
  • 1971 – Kenny Davis – First Team
  • 1974 – Andy Williams – Second Team
  • 1975 – Andy Williams – First Team
  • 1991 – Russell Chadwell – Second Team
  • 1992 – Allen McCowan – First Team
  • 1993 – Mark Tandy – First Team
  • 1993 – Russell Chadwell – Second Team
  • 1994 – Mark Tandy – First Team
  • 1994 – Jason Woodard – Second Team
  • 1995 – Jason Woodard – First Team
  • 1996 – Jermaine Brown – First Team
  • 1998 – Will Carlton
  • 1999 – Barry Bowman – First Team
  • 1999 – Will Carlton – First Team
  • 2000 – Will Carlton – First Team
  • 2002 – Antwan Jones – Second Team
  • 2003 – Quintin Bailey – Second Team
  • 2004 – George Baker – First Team
  • 2004 – Marshall Williams – Third Team
  • 2006 – Brian Silverhorn – Second Team
  • 2008 - Gordon "Gus" Chase - First Team
  • 2008 - Demetrius Guions - Honorable Mention

Women’s Basketball

  • 1992 – Susan VanArsdale – Second Team
  • 1993 – Tammy Kindrick – Second Team
  • 1994 – Tammy Kindrick – Second Team
  • 2002 – Andi Johnson – Second Team
  • 2003 – Andi Johnson – Third Team
  • 2004 – Rachel Vincent – Third Team
  • 2005 – Neeley Thomas – Second Team
  • 2006 – Kim Ingle – Third Team
  • 2008 - Jayme Gilbert - Honorable Mention

Football

  • 1965 – Tom Seals – First Team
  • 1966 – Tom Seals – First Team
  • 1974 – Charles Pierson – Second Team
  • 1976 – Rubin McIntyre – First Team
  • 1978 – John Martinelli – First Team
  • 1983 – Mike Ward – Second Team
  • 1984 – Kent Garrett – Second Team
  • 1985 – Rob McCrary
  • 1986 – Randy Palmer – Academic
  • 1986 – Gerral Wood – Academic
  • 1986 – Forty Jackson – Second Team
  • 1987 – Chris Reed – First Team
  • 1987 – Forty Jackson – Second Team
  • 1988 – Chris Reed – First Team
  • 1988 – Dan Shearer – Second Team
  • 1988 – Mitch Winburn – Second Team
  • 1989 – Mitch Winburn – Second Team
  • 1989 – Steve Blankenbaker – Second Team
  • 1990 – Brian McKenzie
  • 1991 – Chris Hogan – First Team
  • 1991 – Gary Miller – Second Team
  • 1991 – Dane Damron – Second Team
  • 1992 – Chris Hogan
  • 1992 – Dane Damron
  • 1993 – Steve Hill
  • 1995 – Chad McCollam – Second Team
  • 1999 – Shane Pearson – First Team
  • 1999 – Walt DeLong – First Team
  • 1999 – Eddie Eviston – First Team
  • 1999 – Frank Parks – First Team
  • 2000 – Walt DeLong – First Team
  • 2000 – Eddie Eviston – First Team
  • 2000 – Tony Steele – First Team
  • 2000 – Shane Pearson – First Team
  • 2000 – Kevin Davis – Second Team
  • 2001 – Walt DeLong – First Team
  • 2001 – Eddie Eviston – First Team
  • 2002 – Shan Housekeeper – First Team
  • 2002 – Reese Hicks – Second Team
  • 2002 – Sean Cronin – Second Team
  • 2004 – John Michael Sullivan – First Team
  • 2004 – Chris Wergers – Second Team
  • 2004 – Jeff Smith – Second Team
  • 2004 – Michael Hudson – Second Team
  • 2005 – Kenya Williams – First Team
  • 2005 – Gabe Guthrie – Second Team
  • 2006 – Clay Hamblen - First Team
  • 2007 - Clay Hamblen - First Team

Women’s Soccer

  • 2002 - Elizabeth "Lizzie" Brown - Honorable Mention
  • 2004 – Meghan Scott – Third Team
  • 2004 - Leah Crews- Honorable Mention
  • 2004 - Brittany Hunt - Honorable Mention
  • 2005 - Meghan Scott - Honorable Mention

Women’s Tennis

  • 2007 – Emily Kerrick – Honorable Mention
  • 2007 – Sarah Yost – Honorable Mention

Volleyball

  • 1988 – Nancy Hulsmeyer – Honorable Mention
  • 1989 – Nancy Hulsmeyer – Second Team
  • 1990 – Chris Schimmoeller – Third Team
  • 1990 – Jennifer Nuss – Honorable Mention
  • 1991 – Jennifer Nuss – Honorable Mention
  • 1992 – Monica Beam – Honorable Mention
  • 1992 – Nancy Hulsmeyer – First Team
  • 1993 – Monica Beam – Honorable Mention
  • 1993 – Erin Monnier – Honorable Mention
  • 1994 – Erin Monnier – Second Team
  • 1995 – Erin Monnier – Honorable Mention
  • 1996 – Jalana Daeger – Honorable Mention
  • 1998 – Lindsey Thieneman – Honorable Mention
  • 1999 – Susan Clements – Third Team
  • 1999 – Lindsey Thieneman – Second Team
  • 2000 – Susan Clements – First Team
  • 2000 – Lindsey Thieneman – Honorable Mention
  • 2000 – Beth Vieth – Honorable Mention
  • 2001 – Susan Clements – First Team
  • 2001 – Lindsey Thieneman – Honorable Mention
  • 2001 - Beth Vieth - Honorable Mention
  • 2003 - Kara Hellmann - Honorable Mention
  • 2003 - Jessica Leonard - Honorable Mention
  • 2004 - Kara Hellmann - Second Team
  • 2004 - Jessica Leonard - Third Team
  • 2005 – Kara Hellmann – Second Team
  • 2006 – Amy Schiller – Third Team

Georgetown College